Choosing between the Maruti Dzire and Tata Tigor can be challenging. Both are popular compact sedans that offer value for money, safety, and efficiency. However, each has unique features that cater to different needs. Here’s a detailed comparison to help you make the right choice.
1. Safety and Build Quality: An Essential Factor
Safety is critical when selecting a car. Both the Dzire and Tigor score well in this area, with reliable safety ratings.
- Maruti Dzire: This sedan recently earned a 5-star Global NCAP rating for adult occupancy and 3-star for child safety. It comes with dual airbags, ABS with EBD, ESP, Hill Hold Assist (AMT only), and ISOFIX child seat anchors. These features make it a great choice for families and safety-focused drivers who value Maruti’s dependability.
- Tata Tigor: The Tigor holds a 4-star Global NCAP rating. It includes dual airbags, ABS with EBD, corner stability control, rear parking sensors, and ISOFIX mounts. Tata is known for building sturdy cars, and the Tigor lives up to this reputation.
Our Take: With its recent 5-star rating, the Dzire matches the Tigor in safety. Tata’s structural integrity remains an advantage for the Tigor. For safety-conscious buyers, both cars are strong contenders.
2. Engine Performance and Fuel Efficiency: Which Car Offers More?
Performance and fuel economy are crucial for daily drivers. Let’s compare the two.
- Maruti Dzire: The Dzire runs on a 1.2L K-Series Dual Jet, Dual VVT petrol engine. It produces 89 bhp and 113 Nm of torque, delivering a smooth yet efficient performance. With up to 24 km/l (AMT variant) in mileage, it’s perfect for those who prioritize low fuel costs.
- Tata Tigor: The Tigor’s 1.2L Revotron petrol engine offers 84 bhp and 113 Nm of torque. It’s smooth and reliable, though slightly less powerful than the Dzire. The Tigor delivers around 20 km/l and also comes with a CNG variant, ideal for eco-conscious drivers who want extra fuel savings.
Our Take: The Dzire’s efficiency makes it great for daily commutes. However, the Tigor’s CNG variant is excellent for those who seek both fuel savings and an eco-friendly option.
3. Interior Comfort and Features: A Look Inside
Both sedans offer comfort, but each has a unique approach to interiors and technology.
- Maruti Dzire: The Dzire’s spacious cabin includes the 7-inch SmartPlay Studio infotainment system with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay. It also features automatic climate control, steering-mounted controls, and a 378-liter boot. This setup offers plenty of space for passengers and luggage alike.
- Tata Tigor: Tata focuses on comfort and technology in the Tigor. It includes a Harman 7-inch infotainment system known for excellent sound quality. The Tigor’s interior has a cooled glovebox, digital instrument cluster, rear armrest with cup holders, and a larger 419-liter boot.
Our Take: Both cars are comfortable. The Tigor’s Harman sound system and additional features, like the cooled glovebox, add a touch of luxury. The Dzire’s interior is functional, spacious, and ideal for drivers who prefer simplicity.
4. Exterior Design and Styling: Classic vs. Sporty
Style is subjective, but here’s a look at how the Dzire and Tigor appeal to different aesthetics.
- Maruti Dzire: The Dzire has a chrome-accented front grille, LED projector headlamps, and a streamlined design. It’s a refined, understated look that suits drivers who prefer a classic sedan style.
- Tata Tigor: The Tigor features Tata’s signature Humanity Line grille, projector headlamps with LED DRLs, and diamond-cut alloy wheels. With its sharp lines and bold design, the Tigor stands out and has a sporty edge.
Our Take: The Dzire’s elegance will appeal to those who like a sophisticated look. The Tigor’s sporty design is perfect for drivers who prefer something modern and eye-catching.
5. Pricing and Value for Money (On-Road Prices)
Pricing plays a key role in the decision-making process. Here’s how both cars compare in cost.
- Maruti Dzire: On-road prices for the Dzire start at around ₹7.4 lakhs and go up to ₹11.2 lakhs. Given its impressive fuel economy, the Dzire offers great long-term savings.
- Tata Tigor: The Tigor’s on-road price ranges from ₹7.2 lakhs to ₹10.5 lakhs. It provides a solid list of features and a strong build, all at a slightly lower price point.
Our Take: The Dzire’s higher cost is offset by its fuel efficiency, making it a cost-effective choice for frequent drivers. The Tigor provides excellent value with its premium features and lower starting price, ideal for those who want a well-rounded car at a budget-friendly rate.
Summary: Choosing the Right Sedan
Here’s a quick comparison to help you decide between the Maruti Dzire and Tata Tigor:
Feature | Maruti Dzire | Tata Tigor | Our Take |
---|---|---|---|
Safety | 5-star Global NCAP rating, dual airbags, ABS with EBD, ESP, Hill Hold Assist in AMT. | 4-star Global NCAP rating, dual airbags, ABS with EBD, corner stability control, ISOFIX mounts. | Both are safe, but Dzire now matches Tigor, offering strong safety with low maintenance benefits. |
Engine & Fuel Efficiency | 1.2L K-Series, 89 bhp, 113 Nm torque; up to 24 km/l (AMT). | 1.2L Revotron, 84 bhp, 113 Nm torque; around 20 km/l; also available in CNG. | Dzire is ideal for daily commuting with its superior mileage. The Tigor’s CNG option is great for eco-conscious drivers. |
Interior Comfort & Features | SmartPlay Studio with Android Auto/Apple CarPlay, automatic climate control, and 378-liter boot. | Harman audio, Android Auto/Apple CarPlay, digital display, cooled glovebox, rear armrest, 419-liter boot. | Tigor’s Harman system and luxury touches offer a premium experience. Dzire’s interior is spacious, functional, and practical. |
Exterior Styling | Chrome-accented grille, LED projector headlamps, sleek design. | Bold grille, projector headlamps, LED DRLs, diamond-cut wheels, sharp lines. | Dzire is more classic and professional, while Tigor’s sporty style appeals to those who prefer a modern aesthetic. |
Price (On-Road) | ₹7.4 lakhs – ₹11.2 lakhs | ₹7.2 lakhs – ₹10.5 lakhs | Dzire is slightly higher, but it compensates with fuel savings. Tigor offers a lower starting price with great features and strong value. |
Ideal Buyer | Best for commuters, city drivers, and those focused on efficiency and low maintenance. | Great for families, safety-conscious buyers, and those who prefer durability, safety, and tech-rich features. | Dzire suits efficiency-focused drivers. Tigor is ideal for those prioritizing safety, tech, and a modern design. |
Final Verdict
Both the Maruti Dzire and Tata Tigor excel in different areas.
- Choose the Maruti Dzire if you’re looking for maximum fuel efficiency, reliability, and safety. It’s perfect for daily commutes, low maintenance, and long-term savings.
- Choose the Tata Tigor if you value a sturdy build, modern styling, and premium interior touches. It’s especially suitable for families and eco-conscious buyers with its CNG variant and strong safety features.
In the end, both cars offer excellent value. The Dzire is ideal for those seeking efficiency and simplicity, while the Tigor caters to drivers looking for safety, style, and comfort. Both are strong choices in the compact sedan market, so you can feel confident choosing the one that best fits your lifestyle and priorities.